Alone in the Dark Review – PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S

Alone in the Dark Review
The game is a reimagining of the original 1992 Alone in the Dark and the seventh installment in the Alone in the Dark video game series.


In 2024, there was an attempt to bring the seminal survival horror game Alone in the Dark back to life. The game promises a return to the fundamentals of exploration, riddles, and atmosphere, putting Emily Hartwood in the shoes of private investigator Edward Carnby.  It has some good puzzles and a hauntingly gorgeous Derceto Manor to explore, but the experience is ruined by erratic storyline, awkward combat, and a dearth of real scares.

Derceto Manor and Exploration

Derceto Manor is among the best features of the game. The manor, which is the main site, is a multi-story maze with a horrifying past.  Discovering more about Derceto’s past gives the main story more substance, and disturbing findings heighten the suspense.  Discoveries are rewarded with ammo, health boosts, narrative-expanding notes, and mementos known as “Len Yap objects.” Gaining access to weaponry, narrative tidbits, and other bonuses by completing these collector sets inspires exploration of every crevice.

A Flawed Performance

Exploration is excellent, but fighting is a big mistake.  Attacking is imprecise, movement is slow, and enemy animations are clumsy.  Combat stays static the entire time due to the lack of a progression mechanism and the lack of impact of hits.  The division of battle and exploration in the game adds to the already low level of stress.  There’s an odd disconnect because Derceto Manor itself doesn’t have many fight scenes.  Because they have lots of health and ammo, adversaries are not very dangerous, even on the normal difficulty.

Storytelling in the Dark

Another source of contradiction is the narrative.  The history of Derceto and the people who live there are fascinating, but the main characters themselves are unimpressive.  David Harbour’s Carnby and Jodie Comer’s Emily give inconsistent performances.  Their reactions are occasionally out of character due to inconsistent writing and odd audio manipulation.


A mainstay of the survival horror genre, riddles are abundant in Alone in the Dark.  They’re not revolutionary, but they’re attractive and interesting.  The game accommodates both novices and experts by providing an optional “old school” mode that eliminates instructions and enables players to approach puzzles in a more traditional manner.

Technical Jitters

Although it lacks the high fidelity of contemporary horror games, Alone in the Dark can yet have some visually striking scenes.  But the experience is spoiled by technological flaws like lip-syncing problems and sporadic graphic glitches.  More severely, the audio fails, with moments of badly mixed and distorted effects in small areas removing you from the experience.


The game Alone in the Dark has shortcomings as well as potential.  Fans of survival horror will find Derceto Manor’s atmosphere, exploration, and puzzle design to be strong points.  But the game is severely hindered by the shoddy fighting, uneven plot, and dearth of true shocks.  These features might make some people happy, but they can’t nearly make up for the negative aspects of the experience.  In the end, Alone in the Dark feels more like a flashback than a genuine rebirth when it comes to the franchise.

Hope this article on Alone in the Dark Review is helpful. If you have questions regarding this article, feel free to comment down below.


“Alone in the Dark” is a survival horror game set in Derceto Manor, an asylum with a dark history. Players navigate the eerie corridors, solving puzzles and uncovering mysteries while facing supernatural threats.

The protagonists are Edward Carnby, a private investigator, and Emily Hartwood, who hires him to investigate her missing uncle, Jeremy Hartwood.

Despite its flaws, the game offers an engaging experience for survival horror enthusiasts. Its strengths in exploration and atmosphere may outweigh its shortcomings for some players, making it worth a try.

Leave a Comment